In professional color work, the terms lifting and lightening are often used interchangeably—but they aren’t the same. Confusing the two can lead to overprocessed hair, poor tone outcomes, uneven blonding, or wasted corrective efforts.
Understanding the difference between lifting (altering the natural pigment) and lightening (achieving a brighter or paler visual result) is essential for choosing the right product, developer, and timing. This subtle distinction changes everything—from how you formulate, to how you manage client expectations, to how you correct tone issues.
What Is Lifting?
Lifting refers specifically to the process of breaking down the natural melanin in the hair.
It’s a chemical reaction that removes depth and underlying pigment from the natural base color. Lifting occurs with permanent color, high-lift tints, or bleach—each to varying degrees.
Key points about lifting:
-
It works on natural pigment, not artificial color
-
The goal is to raise the level (e.g., from Level 4 to Level 6)
-
It’s measured in “levels of lift” based on the strength of the developer and product
-
It does not guarantee a lighter visual tone—it only means the hair’s base has been chemically shifted
What Is Lightening?
Lightening is the overall visual brightness of the hair. It includes:
-
Removal of both natural and artificial pigment
-
How the light reflects off the remaining tone
-
The tonal clarity and undertone exposed
Hair can be lifted but still look darker or warmer than expected—especially if residual pigment hasn’t been neutralized or removed fully.
Example:
Lifting a Level 6 to a Level 8 with color may technically “lift” the base, but the hair might still appear warm, golden, or dull depending on its undertone and porosity. In contrast, bleach might lighten it further, giving a cleaner, brighter result.
Why It Matters in Practice
1. When Using Permanent Color vs. Bleach
Permanent color lifts and deposits—but it has limits. It can only lift about 2–3 levels and often struggles to lighten beyond Level 7, especially on coarse or dark hair.
Lightening beyond that requires bleach, which removes more pigment and allows toners to work on a cleaner canvas.
2. When Working Over Artificial Color
Color doesn’t lift color. If the client has box dye or previous color buildup, lifting with high-lift tint won’t work. You may lift the natural base beneath—but the artificial pigment will still sit there, blocking lightness.
3. When Toning Over a Poor Lift
If you haven’t lifted far enough, no toner can create the tone you want.
Example: Trying to tone a Level 7 orange-gold to platinum ash will fail—because the lightness isn’t there, even if the hair has technically “lifted.”
How to Adjust Your Process
-
Clarify whether you're targeting lift or lightness. If you want brightness and clarity, use bleach. If you're going for subtle shift or base break, a high-lift tint may be enough.
-
Always evaluate the canvas before toning. Use a level finder or wet strand evaluation to confirm actual lift—not just perceived brightness.
-
Set realistic expectations with clients. Explain that lifting doesn’t guarantee the visual tone they expect, especially in one session.
-
Track undertone exposure. Lifting to Level 8 still means underlying yellow. If lightness is there but tone is wrong, that’s where toning takes over. But it only works if the lift was clean.
